NYCFC Defeats Portland Timbers on Penalties in Dramatic 2021 MLS Cup Final

American goalkeeper Sean Johnson also starred for NYCFC, stopping two of the four PK’s he faced.

Portland was in search of its second MLS Cup title after having won for the first time in 2015, and it has now lost in the final twice in the past four years, as it fell 2-0 to Atlanta United FC in 2018.

The Timbers were on the road in each of their first two MLS Cup appearances, but they hosted this time around, and the atmosphere was awesome at Providence Park thanks to the capacity crowd and rainy weather:

NYCFC brought a slice of home with it to the Pacific Northwest, however, as New York Yankees manager Aaron Boone was present to watch The Boys in Blue:

The first half was largely a feeling-out process due in part to the weather, and the rain undoubtedly played a huge role in the opening goal of the game.

Golden Boot winner Valentin Castellanos got NYCFC on the board first in the 41st minute when he headed a set piece from a hobbled Maxi Moralez past Portland goalkeeper Steve Clark:

It was likely a shot Clark would have saved in better conditions, but Felipe Cardenas of The Athletic suggested Clark should have been able to handle it regardless:

Amid the chaos of the goal and NYCFC’s celebration, an ugly moment occurred in the form of a fan throwing an object onto the field.

NYCFC’s Jesus Medina got hit in the face with a can and was down on the field for a few minutes, but he eventually got up and stayed in the game:

Former MLS and United States Men’s National Team forward Herculez Gomez called for the fan who threw the can to be identified and banned:

The Timbers later confirmed that the fan had been ejected from the stadium and banned:

NYCFC largely went into a defensive shell in the second half in an effort to protect the 1-0 lead, and it looked as though it was going to work until disaster struck in stoppage time.

Mora scored a desperation goal in the fourth minute of stoppage time in the second half just before the final whistle was about to blow, evening the score at 1-1 and forcing extra time:

While the Timbers and their fans erupted in delight, several NYCFC players were furious that a foul wasn’t called on Portland’s Larrys Mabaila for taking down NYCFC defender Maxime Chanot.

The goal was controversial, but New Orleans Saints running back Mark Ingram seemed to enjoy the moment:

After both clubs played to a stalemate in extra time, the match went to penalties, marking only the fifth time in MLS Cup history that it was decided by a penalty shootout.

Castellanos scored on the first attempt for NYCFC, and each of the next three attempts were stopped, including two by Johnson.

In the end, it was Callens who put it away with a confident penalty and brought New York its first MLS title.