Shining potential of missing atoms: Single-atom vacancies in atomically thin insulators created in ultra-high vacuum

Transmission electron microscopy allows us to see the atomic structure of materials, and it is particularly well suited to directly reveal any defects in the lattice of the specimen, which may be detrimental or useful depending on the application. However, the energetic electron beam may also damage the structure, either due to elastic collisions or electronic excitations, or a combination of both. Further, any gases left in the vacuum of the instrument can contribute to damage, whereby dissociated gas molecules can etch away atoms of the lattice. Until now, transmission electron microscopy measurements of hBN have been conducted at relatively poor vacuum conditions, leading to rapid damage. Due to this limitation, it has not been clear whether vacancies — single missing atoms — can be controllably created.

At the University of Vienna, the creation of single atomic vacancies has now been achieved using aberration-corrected scanning transmission electron microscopy in near ultra-high vacuum. The material was irradiated at a range of electron-beam energies, which influences the measured damage rate. At low energies, damage is dramatically slower than previously measured under poorer residual vacuum conditions. Single boron and nitrogen vacancies can be created at intermediate electron energies, and boron is twice as likely to be ejected due to its lower mass. Although atomically precise measurements are not feasible at the higher energies previously used to make hBN emit single photons, the results predict that nitrogen in turn becomes easier to eject — allowing these shining vacancies to be preferentially created.

Robust statistics collected by painstaking experimental work combined with new theoretical models were vital for reaching these conclusions. Lead author Thuy An Bui has worked on the project since her Master’s thesis: “At each electron energy, I needed to spend many days at the microscope carefully collecting one series of data after another,” she says. “Once the data was collected, we used machine learning to help analyse it accurately, though even this took a great deal of work.” Senior author Toma Susi adds: “To understand the damage mechanism, we created an approximate model that combines ionization with knock-on damage. This allowed us to extrapolate to higher energies and shed new light on defect creation.”

Despite its insulating nature, the results show that monolayer hexagonal boron nitride is surprisingly stable under electron irradiation when chemical etching can be prevented. In the future, it may be possible to use electron irradiation to purposefully create specific vacancies that emit single photons of light by selectively irradiating the desired lattice sites with a focused electron probe. New opportunities for atomically precise manipulation, until now demonstrated for impurity atoms in graphene and in bulk silicon, may also be uncovered.

The work was supported by the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme (Grant agreement No. 756277-ATMEN) and by the Vienna Doctoral School in Physics (VDS-P). Open data and code are provided with the publication.